Cardiac surgery
Conventional surgery means gaining direct access to the heart or aorta. The surgeon sees and touches the structure being repaired: sews bypass grafts onto the coronary arteries, repairs or replaces a valve, replaces a section of the aorta with a graft, or closes a defect with a patch.
Access. Traditionally through a sternotomy — a lengthwise division of the breastbone, which gives a full view of all the structures of the heart and allows several procedures to be performed during a single operation. Minimally invasive approaches are used increasingly often: a mini-sternotomy (dividing only the upper part of the breastbone), a mini-thoracotomy (a 5–8 cm incision between the ribs, with the breastbone left intact) or an approach using a camera and video-assisted instruments. "Minimally invasive" refers to the way in, not to the repair itself — inside, the same operation is performed, only through a smaller opening. This shortens recovery and reduces bleeding, but not every anatomy and not every combination of conditions allows it.
Cardiopulmonary bypass. Most operations require the heart to be stopped. During the operation the work of the heart and lungs is taken over by the heart-lung machine (cardiopulmonary bypass machine), run by a perfusionist; the heart is stopped with a cardioplegic solution and protected by cooling. Once the repair is complete, the heart starts beating again and the machine is disconnected. Some coronary artery operations can be performed on the beating heart, without the heart-lung machine, using a stabiliser that holds still the part of the heart being operated on.
What surgery offers. Durability: an arterial bypass graft or a repaired native valve lasts for decades. Completeness: in a single operation it is possible to repair a valve, perform bypasses, carry out ablation of an arrhythmia, close the atrial appendage and replace the aorta. The ability to treat anatomy that a catheter cannot reach. The price: greater trauma, general anaesthesia, several days in hospital, weeks of recovery and, after a sternotomy, 6–8 weeks of protecting the breastbone.
Endovascular (transcatheter) procedures
In a transcatheter procedure the heart or aorta is reached through a blood vessel — most often the femoral artery or vein in the groin — with a thin catheter, along which a valve, stent graft, occluder or clip is delivered. Everything is done under imaging guidance: fluoroscopy (X-rays) and echocardiography, usually transoesophageal. The procedure is performed in a hybrid operating room by a team of interventional cardiologists and cardiac surgeons.
The principle. Instead of removing the diseased structure, a new one is added or its function is changed from the inside: a TAVI valve presses the calcified valve against the wall of the aorta and takes over its function; a stent graft excludes an aneurysm from the circulation without removing it; a clip joins the leaflets of a leaking valve; an occluder fills the atrial appendage or closes a septal defect. The heart keeps beating throughout; there is no heart-lung machine, and often no general anaesthesia either.
What a transcatheter procedure offers. Minimal trauma: a puncture in the groin instead of a chest wound. A short stay (usually 2–4 days) and a return to activity within one to two weeks. The possibility of treating patients for whom surgery would be too much of a burden. The price: dependence on anatomy (the vessels must allow the system to be introduced, and the target structure must allow it to be anchored), risks specific to the method (for valves — conduction disturbances and the need for a pacemaker, paravalvular leak; for stent grafts — endoleaks and the need for lifelong imaging follow-up), a shorter follow-up history than for surgery, which matters in younger patients, and the fact that one catheter procedure usually treats one condition.
Hybrid procedures
The two approaches are not mutually exclusive. Hybrid treatment combines minimally invasive surgery with a transcatheter procedure: an arterial bypass to the left anterior descending branch performed through a mini-thoracotomy, with stents placed in the remaining vessels; aortic arch surgery with a simultaneous stent graft in the descending aorta (the frozen elephant trunk technique); ligation of the atrial appendage from outside the pericardium combined with access through the blood vessels. The aim is always the same: to take from each method what, in the given case, gives the best result with the least trauma.
How the method is chosen
The decision is made by the Heart Team — a team in which a cardiologist, an interventional cardiologist, a cardiac surgeon and, if needed, an anaesthetist, a radiologist and an imaging specialist discuss the individual patient. They take into account:
- anatomy — assessed with echocardiography, coronary angiography and CT angiography; it is anatomy that most often decides whether a transcatheter procedure is feasible at all;
- surgical risk — calculated with scores (EuroSCORE II, STS), but also an assessment of frailty, fitness, and kidney, lung and liver function;
- age and life expectancy — in younger patients what counts is a solution that lasts for decades; in older patients — safety and a quick return to independence;
- the number of conditions to be treated — if a valve needs to be repaired and bypasses performed at the same time, surgery deals with everything in one go;
- guidelines — the European ESC/EACTS recommendations specify in which situations each method has an advantage proven in clinical trials;
- the patient's preferences — after an honest conversation about the benefits and risks of both approaches; the patient has the right to hear the arguments for each of them and to ask why one was proposed rather than the other.
There is no method that is "better" in general. There is a method that is better for a given patient, at a given stage of the disease. The same aortic stenosis means surgery in a 55-year-old patient with a bicuspid valve and a dilated aorta, and TAVI in an 82-year-old patient with kidney failure.
What this means for the patient
Before a consultation it is worth having the results of the tests on which the assessment is based: coronary angiography and echocardiography (always) and, depending on the condition, CT angiography of the heart, aorta or coronary arteries, and cardiac MRI. On this basis three questions can be answered: whether a procedure is needed now, by which route it can be performed, and what each route means in practice — how many days in hospital, what restrictions, which medicines and what check-ups afterwards.